Approved Group International
The above picture shows initial stroke of signature A on exhibit E2 showing steep straight upstroke.
All insights

Signature Authorship Determination

The forensic team of Approved Forensics Sdn Bhd (AFSB) was approached to determine the authorship of signatures on agreement documents.

1 min read

The forensic team of Approved Forensics Sdn Bhd (AFSB) was approached to determine the authorship of signatures on agreement documents. Since the agreement involves legal transactions, clients required our service to determine if the signatures on the questioned documents and the reference documents are signed by the same person. The questioned signature will be hereafter known as signature A throughout this article. Our team were provided with four different exhibits containing signatures for authorship determination purpose. The exhibits were labelled as E2, E3, E4, and E5 respectively. The signatures were subjected to microscopical and macroscopical analysis where features like alignment, initial strokes and terminal stroke morphology, connecting stroke, pen width, line quality, I-dots and T-bars of the signatures were visually compared. This was done to determine if the signatures were signed by the same signers. The initial strokes of signature A on exhibits E2, E4 and E5 were made as a steep straight upstroke whereas the upstroke of E3 appears slightly curved as represented in Figure 1.

Figure 1: Comparison of the morphology of initial stroke formation of Signature A

The above picture shows initial stroke of signature A on exhibit E3 showing slight curvature in the upstroke.
The above picture shows initial stroke of signature A on exhibit E4 showing steep straight upstroke.
The above picture shows initial stroke of signature A on exhibit E5 showing steep straight upstroke.

The terminal strokes of signature A on exhibits E2, E4 and E5 were made as a straight downstroke without tailing but the terminal stroke of E3 is made as a curve with tailing as shown in Figure 2.

Figure 2: Comparison of the morphology of terminal stroke formation of Signature A

The above picture shows terminal stroke of signature A on exhibit E2 showing straight downstroke.
The above picture shows terminal stroke of signature A on exhibit E3 showing curved downstroke with tailing.
The above picture shows terminal stroke of signature A on exhibit E4 showing straight downstroke.
The above picture shows terminal stroke of signature A on exhibit E5 showing straight downstroke.

The stroke indicated by green line is made as a continuous stroke without a pen lift in E2, E4 and E5 but a pen lift is evident in signature A on E3 (refer Figure 3).

Figure 3: Comparison of stroke formation of Signature A

The above picture shows strokes of signature A on exhibit E2 made as a continuous stroke.
The above picture shows strokes of signature A on exhibit E3 made as separate strokes.
The above picture shows strokes of signature A on exhibit E4 made as a continuous stroke.
The above picture shows strokes of signature A on exhibit E5 made as a continuous stroke.

Based on a thorough visual comparison of signatures on questioned and reference documents, AFSB’s forensic team concluded that signer on exhibits E2, E4 and E5 is inconsistent with signer for exhibit E3.

Keep reading

Related insights

All insights
  • Figure 1: Classification and grouping of explosives.

    ArticleForensic Investigation

    Explosions (Dust Explosion)

    Explosives are materials that produce violent chemical or nuclear reactions. Explosive material is a reactive substance that contains a great amount of…

    By AGI Team3 min read
    Read the article
  • Figure 1: Transmission of Transient Voltage through the Start-Finish Data Cable

    Case StudyForensic Investigation

    Lightning Investigation

    A Reverse Angle Photo Finish Camera (RAPFC), located at the finishing post of a horse racing track, was reported to have failed. The incident was discovered by…

    By AGI Team2 min read
    Read the case study
  • Figure 1: General view of the extent of fire damage onto the roof of the Restaurant B (red arrow) and the newly erected cement wall on top of the pre-existing low-level wall after the fire (blue arrow).

    Case StudyForensic Investigation

    Fire Investigation to Restaurant

    Approved Forensics Sdn Bhd (AFSB)’s Team received an assignment to investigate the origin of a fire involving 2 adjoining restaurants. Besides the cause fire…

    By AGI Team2 min read
    Read the case study

24/7 response

Does this affect a claim you are handling?

Send us the detail and we will tell you what a proper investigation would need to establish.