Approved Group International
Agi damage assessment of 1 lift and 6 escalators view of affected escalator photograph
All insights

Damage Assessment of 1 lift and 6 escalators

At approximately 1530 hours on Monday, 6 March 2017, an outflow of water from at level 7M2 was reported within SC Shopping Centre (hereinafter referred to as…

1 min read

At approximately 1530 hours on Monday, 6 March 2017, an outflow of water from at level 7M2 was reported within SC Shopping Centre (hereinafter referred to as SC), located at, Cheras, Kuala Lumpur, Malaysia.

The water allegedly originated from damaged coupling causing the water to burst out from the fire sprinkler system and damaged properties including elevator and escalators, which were at the final phase of the construction at the time. The Approved Forensics Sdn Bhd (AFSB) Team examined in detail, the water-affected lift and escalators and their components.

Agi damage assessment of 1 lift and 6 escalators view of the affected escalator from front view at level 2 photograph
Agi damage assessment of 1 lift and 6 escalators afsb teams detailed examination on the affected parts of escalator photograph
Agi damage assessment of 1 lift and 6 escalators view of lift from inside of the lift car photograph
Agi damage assessment of 1 lift and 6 escalators view of the car top photograph
Agi damage assessment of 1 lift and 6 escalators afsb teams detailed examination on the affected lift parts photograph

Based on the damage analysis and information acquired, the extent of damage varied amongst the lift and escalators. Most of the components were damaged by water and replacements were recommended. However, we were also presented with components which did not display any signs of contact or damage by water. As for those components which did not display any signs of water damage or any physical damage, the Team requested the vendor to have them tested for its functionality. The Team’s proposal was to ‘swap-test’ these components to verify if they were damaged. The lift vendor was unable to provide a satisfactory testing method to proof their claim, and hence we disregarded these parts. As for the escalators, the Team couldn’t support the vendor’s contention of ‘pre-emptive’ replacement without proof of any physical damage. The Team proposed servicing these components as the exposure to elevated humidity and effects of moisture on these components couldn’t be ruled out.

Keep reading

Related insights

All insights
  • The Mechanical Drive Truck (MDT) shows a "V" -pattern on its nearside.

    ArticleDamage Assessment

    Fire to a Mechanical Drive Truck

    A Mechanical Drive Truck (MDT) in a mining area of Kalimantan, caught on fire while it was being operated and while waiting to be filled with soil.

    By AGI Team2 min read
    Read the article
  • Agi water damage assessment the signs of corrosion on the aircraft cord red arrow

    ArticleDamage Assessment

    Water Damage Assessment

    Water, as simple as it sounds, can cause hundreds to thousands worth of damage. Various items can be damaged by water such as wood furniture, carpets…

    By AGI Team2 min read
    Read the article
  • Agi collision damage classification figure

    Technical NoteDamage Assessment

    Collision Damage Classification

    Collision Damage Classification (CDC, per SAE MAR80 J224) is an excellent tool to provide a clear and concise description to the principal direction of force…

    By AGI Team2 min read
    Read the technical note

24/7 response

Does this affect a claim you are handling?

Send us the detail and we will tell you what a proper investigation would need to establish.