Approved Group International
AGI marine surveyor in a hard hat and orange vest recording damaged cargo in a barge hold on a tablet

Forensic Investigation

Marine Cargo Damage Investigation

Marine cargo damage investigation establishes whether the damage found is consistent with the voyage, the handling and the stowage described, and what portion of a consignment is genuinely affected.

When to call

  • Cargo arrives damaged and the cause is disputed.
  • Recovery against a carrier, forwarder, stevedore or packing contractor.
  • An industrial incident during loading, discharge or lifting.
  • Pre-loss.

What you receive

  • AGI may be instructed by any party requiring an independent finding on cargo damage.
  • Whoever gives the instruction, the engagement generally produces preliminary advice, often within days of site access, so that decisions which…
  • Many of our engineers and consultants hold chartered or professional registrations relevant to the jurisdictions in which they practise.
  • A shipment routinely crosses more borders than the dispute over it ever does: manufactured in one country, financed in a second, moving through a…

What Is Marine Cargo Damage Investigation?

A cargo survey records what is damaged, counts the loss and advises on salvage value. It is usually the first assessment made, and it stops short of the question that decides most disputes. A marine cargo damage investigation asks why the goods were damaged, and whether the mechanism is consistent with the voyage described. It asks whether packing, dunnage, securing and stowage were adequate to the transit undertaken, and whether the damage predates the voyage. On a large consignment, the gap between a cause finding grounded in testing and a precautionary rejection based on appearance is usually the largest single figure at stake. We work alongside the marine surveyor already on the file, not in place of it.

How We Investigate

Document and evidence review. Bill of lading, packing list, manifest, loss notification, discharge photographs and the surveyor's preliminary report.

Container inspection. The container or crate, examined for structural integrity, seal condition and evidence of how it was loaded, alongside the goods themselves.

Photographic and dimensional survey. A complete visual and measured record made before anything is moved or discarded, so the finding can be reviewed years later.

Damage characterisation. Visual and microscopic examination distinguishes impact damage, water ingress, corrosion and vibration-related failure, mapping which units are affected against which are not.

Moisture and condensation analysis. Condensation that formed inside a sealed container looks different from seawater ingress through a failed seal. Both look different again from corrosion present before the voyage began.

Sampling. A statistically defensible protocol where a consignment runs to hundreds or thousands of units and cannot be inspected one by one.

Laboratory testing. Gas chromatography-mass spectrometry and ion chromatography where contamination is in question, and functional or cycle testing against manufacturer specification for electronic and battery cargo, where the cause is disputed.

Repairability and salvage assessment. , concluding in a report on cause, consistency with the event described, and the basis for a partial or total loss position. Where the evidence permits, the remaining cause or contributing causes are reported; where it does not permit a reliable determination, that limitation is stated.

Toppled wooden crate holding a large machine component on a flatrack container, its lashings snapped
Plate 01Toppled wooden crate holding a large machine component on a flatrack container, its lashings snapped

What We Investigate

Containerised general cargo. Water ingress and condensation damage, container integrity failure, and stow and lashing failure. Contamination discovered inside a sealed container after a voyage that gave no reason to expect it.

Project and heavy-lift cargo. Machinery and process equipment moved as project cargo, including toppling, lifting and rigging incidents during load-out or discharge. The securing calculation for an oversized unit is itself part of the evidence.

Precision equipment and electronics in transit. Servers, inverters, medical and laboratory instruments and other sensitive equipment, where the central question is usually whether a unit is safe to return to service or must be replaced.

Vehicles and parts. Automotive components, spare parts and safety-critical items such as airbag inflators. A sampling and functional-test regime decides the scope of the loss here, not a visual check.

Chemicals, drums and liquids. Bulk and drummed chemical cargo, contamination and cross-contamination questions, and chain-of-custody reconstruction from loading point to delivery.

Temperature-controlled cargo. Reefer and cold-chain shipments, where the investigation turns on the temperature record and whether any excursion is consistent with the loss reported.

Inland transit and lifting incidents. Damage on the inland leg of a shipment, and incidents during lifting or handling at a port, yard or site, including overload analysis of the equipment involved.

Damage discovered at the terminal. Condition noted at discharge, before a container has even left the port, where the question is often whether the damage happened at sea or during handling ashore.

What Decides These Cases

Condition on shipment against condition on delivery. A pre-shipment survey, packing photographs or a clean bill of lading carry weight against damage said to have occurred entirely in transit. Where they do not exist, the baseline has to be reconstructed from indirect evidence.

Whether the moisture pattern fits the route, the season and the container type. Condensation inside a steel container on a long tropical voyage behaves differently from seawater ingress through a failed seal. Both look different again from corrosion that had already begun before loading. The pattern of the damage, not its presence, usually answers the question.

Securing and stowage adequacy. Whether bracing, lashing and dunnage were adequate to the cargo's weight, shape and the motion expected on the voyage undertaken. The judgement is made against the standard a competent packer would have applied, not against the fact that damage occurred.

Sampling methodology, where a consignment is too large to inspect unit by unit. A defensible sample, tested against a stated specification and reported with its confidence, decides losses running to thousands of units within a practical budget. An indefensible sample decides nothing, however large it is.

Water-damaged cartons of electronics inside an opened shipping container
Plate 02Water-damaged cartons of electronics inside an opened shipping container

Common questions

About marine cargo damage investigation

The questions that come up before an instruction, answered plainly.

24/7 response

Protect the evidence first

Restrict access, change nothing, and call. Most of what decides a case is still on site in the first few days.

Emergency line open at all hours, across every office.